Early hi-def DVD buyers like what they see

[Ricardo Ribeiro]

LOS ANGELES (Hollywood Reporter)- Early adopters who bought one of the first two Toshiba high-definition DVD players had mixed comments about the official start of packaged media's high-definition era.

ADVERTISEMENT

Most gave the players high marks -- for quality and value -- but faulted the format's supporters for having just three movies in stores when the machines arrived April 18.

James Stevenson, a 22-year-old freelance journalist in Lincoln, Neb., said he bought the cheaper of the two Toshiba players -- Toshiba's Web site prices them at $799.99 and $499.99 -- "because I wanted to get a head start on the next-generation DVDs and give my HD-starved TV more content."

While Stevenson was dismayed at the meager selection of software, he said the player made his standard DVDs look significantly better. "I'm thrilled with that result," he said.

Lars Peterson, 29, of Cape Girardeau, Mo., agrees. He bought two of the three launch titles, "Serenity" and "The Last Samurai," and found the picture quality "breathtaking." (The other launch title was "The Phantom of the Opera.")

But the real treat was watching standard DVDs on his new player. "I have owned at least 10 DVD players over the last eight years," he said, "and I can honestly say the Toshiba player is the best. This is a huge plus, considering the lack of HD movies to currently choose from."

Most early adopters interviewed say they also will buy Blu-ray players when they become available in June, though some balked at the higher prices -- despite conventional wisdom that for early adopters price is generally not a factor.

"Honestly, I am turned off by the higher price tags," said Bryan Ferriera, 33, of Peabody, Mass. "Now that HD-DVD is out, why would anyone want to pay at least double the price of the (cheaper Toshiba) HD-A1 to get the same quality?"

"I actually believe Blu-ray is a better technology, but not at twice the price," said Daniel Rainey, 31, of Tuscaloosa, Ala. "I will buy Blu-ray if they win the war, but that Betamax war lasted eight years before VHS started winning. I ain't waiting that long."

Reuters/VNU

[Edward Brock]

Entretanto, embora falem bem da qualidade de imagem, os tipos do The Digital Bits vão dando a chamada "Sova do Catano" pela fraca fiabilidade dos leitores. Com os últimos romores a darem a PS3 por cerca de $399, a coisa ainda vai aquecer.

[Skywatcher]

E como... autch...

"First of all, the HD-A1 we've managed to borrow temporarily for our review work is just a total lemon. As we've reported before, it repeatedly locks up during playback - completely locks up, including non-responsive controls - forcing you to have to unplug the unit and plug it in again to reboot it. When the unit doesn't completely lock up, we get frequent instances where the video stutters and freezes for a moment, after which time the audio is no longer in sync. Both of these problems aren't getting any better and that (along with the fact that it takes about a minute and a half to get the HD-A1 back into playback mode with discs each time you reboot) has really made it difficult to review the movie software effectively. About half of the readers who own the HD-A1 that we've heard from thus far are reporting similar problems, while the fortunate other half say their units are bug-free. We envy you bug-free folks."

Bem, era de se esperar. A Toshiba não tinha sequer um protótipo funcional do A1 (o mais barato) na CES. Para já estar no mercado tinha que vir necessariamente com bugs... Vamos lá a ver se não lhes sai cara a brincadeira. Penso que não, daqui a uns tempos ninguém se lembra.

A Sony entretanto, cedendo às pressões de Pioneer e Samsung, parece que decidiu não por os Blu-Ray (filmes) no mercado já em maio, mas sim só a 6 de Junho, para preceder apenas em alguns dias os leitores dos 2 fabricantes, que temiam que os filmes 1 mês nas prateleiras sem leitores causassem um "esfriar" do entusiasmo por parte dos consumidores.

Um abraço,